Donald Trump’s political resurgence last fall was significantly fueled by younger men, a demographic he actively courted through various online platforms. However, there are growing signs that some of the most influential voices within the “manosphere”—a collection of male comedians, pranksters, streamers, and right-leaning influencers—are now expressing doubts and even regret regarding his second term. This shift raises questions about the stability of Trump’s support among this crucial voting bloc and opens potential avenues for Democrats.
Key Influencers Voice Discontent
Several prominent figures who once championed Trump are now openly criticising his administration. Joe Rogan, whose interview with Trump preceded his endorsement, has described the new administration’s immigration crackdown as “insane.”
Theo Von, a comedian whose viral interview with Trump signalling a shift among millennial and Gen Z men, has publicly called Trump’s bombing of Iran a “horrible idea,” suggesting it makes the US appear to be “working for Israel.” Even Elon Musk, a key figure in the online media landscape and former Trump ally, is now at odds with the president over his legislative agenda and has threatened to back a third party. Comedian Andrew Schulz, a Trump supporter last year, has stated that the president is “doing the exact opposite of everything I voted for.” This discontent even extends to unexpected corners, with professional poker players criticising changes in tax law they feel unfairly target them.
Shifting Sentiments Among Young Male Voters
These sentiments are resonating with Trump’s supporters on the ground. Justin Centres, a 21-year-old autoworker who voted for Trump, now feels “a little iffy” due to the president’s perceived broken promise of “no new wars.” While some, like Steven Deuby, a 34-year-old mail carrier, acknowledge criticisms but remain broadly supportive, others, like Tyler Goldsmith, a 32-year-old lawn-care business owner, are willing to give Trump the benefit of the doubt for now.
Polling data suggests a tangible shift in approval among younger men. A recent CNN poll conducted by SSRS indicates that among men younger than 35, only 40% approve of Trump’s job performance, a notable decline from 44% in February. This growing disapproval signals a potential challenge for Republicans in future elections.
The Epstein Case: A Tipping Point for Some
One particularly contentious issue fueling discontent within the manosphere is the administration’s handling of the Jeffrey Epstein case. The Department of Justice’s conclusion that Epstein killed himself in prison and did not keep a list of elite clients has sparked outrage among many who were led to believe otherwise by figures within Trump’s orbit.
The CNN poll reveals that 65% of men younger than 35 are dissatisfied with the information released about the case. This dissatisfaction is seen by many as an insult to their intelligence. Despite Trump’s plea for his supporters to move on from the Epstein outrage, it has proven to be a “final straw” for some, leading them to question their vote.
Democrats See an Opening
Amid this growing dissatisfaction, Democrats are making efforts to engage with the manosphere. Figures like Pete Buttigieg, James Talarico, Ro Khanna, and even Minnesota Governor Tim Walz have appeared on podcasts and platforms previously dominated by right-leaning voices.
This willingness to engage directly with these influencers, providing “unfiltered interviews,” is being appreciated by some listeners who are keen to hear diverse perspectives. The shift from Trump-centric content to a more balanced political discussion by these influential male voices reflects their self-proclaimed independence from traditional party lines and presents a unique opportunity for Democrats to connect with a demographic they previously struggled to reach.
